Cake Batter Cookie Thins Crumbl Review (A Simpler Cookie That Starts a Pricing Debate)
The Cake Batter Cookie Thins Crumbl are not designed to overwhelm you.
There’s no thick frosting swirl.
No stuffed center.
No towering 800-calorie cookie.
Instead, Crumbl gives you two thin cookies with rainbow sprinkles and a warm vanilla cake batter flavor.
That simplicity is either exactly what you want or the reason you skip them.
If you want to know whether they’re currently available, check the Crumbl menu this week.
Check if Cake Batter Cookie Thins are part of this week’s Crumbl lineup.
Two Thin Cookies Change the Entire Experience
Most Crumbl cookies are oversized and built for sharing.
These are intentionally lighter.
The set includes:
- two thin cookies,
- crisp outer edges,
- and chewy centers.
Because each cookie is much thinner, the texture feels more like a bakery crisp than a dense gourmet cookie.
Compared to the frosted Cake Batter Crumbl Cookie, this version is far more restrained.
The Flavor Is Pure Cake Batter
Without frosting, the focus shifts entirely to the dough.
The flavor profile delivers:
- vanilla,
- butter,
- and a sweet birthday-cake character.
The rainbow sprinkles reinforce the nostalgic “boxed cake mix” feel.
This concept resembles classic birthday cake cookies, where sprinkles and vanilla batter create a celebration-style flavor without needing additional toppings.
Crisp Edges, Chewy Centers
The thin format works because it introduces contrast.
The edges are:
- crisp,
- lightly caramelized,
- and slightly crunchy.
The centers remain soft and chewy.
That balance makes these feel more polished than store-bought sugar cookies, even if they are less dramatic than many options in the Crumbl cookie flavors list.
Why Reviews Are So Divided
Customer reactions tend to focus less on flavor and more on perceived value.
Fans appreciate:
- lighter portion size,
- no frosting overload,
- and balanced texture.
Critics point to:
- premium pricing,
- smaller size,
- and a flavor they consider too simple.
The official app rating remains strong, but Reddit discussions often question whether two thin cookies should cost as much as a full gourmet cookie.
Calories and Price
Nutrition for the full set of two cookies:
- 390 calories
- 15g fat
- 52g carbohydrates
- 36g sugar
Typical price:
- $4.49–$4.99
Compared to products listed under Crumbl cookie prices, this is one of the lowest-calorie offerings, but also one of the most debated in terms of value.
Availability (A Thin Thursdays Experiment)
The Cake Batter Cookie Thins were created specifically for Crumbl’s Thin Thursdays lineup.
That means they are:
- limited in availability,
- not part of the standard rotating menu,
- and less likely to return as Mystery Cookies.
Because this format differs from Crumbl’s oversized signature cookies, availability can be inconsistent.
To see whether local stores are carrying them, use the Crumbl locations page.
You can also preview future menu changes on the Crumbl flavors next week page.
If you prefer lighter desserts, checking the Crumbl flavors next week page is a smart way to track future Cookie Thins releases.
Explore More Crumbl Cookies
Cake Batter Crumbl Cookie
The full-sized frosted version with a much richer and sweeter profile.
Confetti Cake Crumbl Cookie
A celebration-style cookie topped with frosting and colorful sprinkles.
Pink Sugar Crumbl Cookie
Another vanilla-forward classic that highlights sweetness and texture.
Explore more sprinkle-filled favorites in the complete Crumbl cookie flavors list.
Cake Batter Cookie Thins Crumbl FAQs
Final Verdict
The Cake Batter Cookie Thins Crumbl succeed if you want the flavor of birthday cake without the heaviness of a frosted gourmet cookie.
They offer:
- crisp edges,
- chewy centers,
- and nostalgic vanilla flavor
in a smaller, lower-calorie format.
Whether they feel worth the price depends entirely on how much you value portion size versus simplicity.
If you care most about flavor and texture, they’re an enjoyable change of pace.
If you judge Crumbl by sheer indulgence, they may feel underwhelming.
Explore more classic and celebration-inspired cookies in the complete Crumbl cookie flavors list.