Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins Review (The Cookie That Barely Feels Like Crumbl)
The Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins are probably the least “Crumbl-like” product the company has released.
That is not automatically a bad thing.
Instead of giant frosted cookies, this format delivers:
- two thin dark cocoa cookies,
- crushed cookies & cream pieces,
- white chocolate drizzle,
- and scattered white chips.
There is no buttercream mountain.
No cream cheese frosting.
No stuffed center.
That simplicity completely changes the eating experience.
You can check whether they’re part of the Crumbl menu this week.
Check if Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins are available on this week’s Crumbl menu.
The Dark Cocoa Base Carries the Entire Flavor
Because there’s no frosting layer, the cookie dough itself has to do all the work.
The thin base combines:
- dark cocoa,
- cookies & cream crumbs,
- and buttery dough.
The flavor lands somewhere between:
- an Oreo crisp,
- and a thin brownie cookie.
The cocoa profile is similar to desserts inspired by OREO® cookies, using darker chocolate notes to offset sweetness.
Compared to the standard Cookies & Cream Crumbl Cookie, this version tastes noticeably lighter and less sugary.
The Texture Is the Real Selling Point
Texture—not flavor—is what separates this cookie from the rest of Crumbl’s lineup.
The edges are:
- highly caramelized,
- crisp,
- and crunchy.
The center stays:
- thin,
- buttery,
- and slightly chewy.
That contrast creates a snack-like feel rather than a full dessert experience.
Among options in the Crumbl cookie flavors list, almost nothing else prioritizes crunch over softness this aggressively.
The White Chocolate Balance Problem
The white drizzle and chips add creaminess and sweetness.
But they also create the cookie’s biggest risk.
If the dark cocoa base is deeply baked, the white chocolate balances the bitterness beautifully.
If the cookie is underdeveloped or lightly baked, the sweetness can dominate the finish.
That imbalance explains the mixed Reddit reactions.
Real Customer Reactions: Refreshing or Disappointing
The community response to Crumbl Thins is extremely revealing.
Fans say:
- “Finally a Crumbl cookie I can finish comfortably.”
- “Crunchy edges are amazing.”
- “Less sugar fatigue than normal Crumbl cookies.”
Critics say:
- “Doesn’t feel worth the same price.”
- “Too thin and overcooked.”
- “Missing the signature Crumbl indulgence.”
That last criticism appears constantly in discussions. People who love thick, soft cookies often see the Thins line as a completely different category of dessert.
Calories and Price
Nutrition for the full 2-cookie set:
- 370–410 calories
- 22–26g fat
- 48–52g carbohydrates
- 34–40g sugar
Typical pricing:
- $4.50–$4.99
Compared to items listed under Crumbl cookie prices, the value perception is lower because customers receive less dough and less volume than standard Crumbl cookies.
Availability (The Experimental Line Designed for Portion-Conscious Customers)
The Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins belong to Crumbl’s specialized Thins program.
Unlike standard rotating cookies, these are intentionally designed for:
- lighter portions,
- crunchier textures,
- and less overwhelming sweetness.
They target a different customer than Crumbl’s traditional audience.
Availability varies heavily by location because not all stores emphasize the Thins lineup equally.
You can check nearby stores using the Crumbl locations page.
You can also preview upcoming rotations on the Crumbl flavors next week page.
If you prefer lighter desserts over giant frosted cookies, watch the Crumbl flavors next week page for future Thins releases.
Explore More Crumbl Cookies
Chocolate Cookies & Cream Crumbl Cookie
A thicker, gooier Oreo-inspired cookie with a dense cocoa base.
Cookies & Cream White Chip Crumbl Cookie
A softer marbled cookie with melted white chocolate throughout.
Cake Batter Cookie Thins
Another thin-format release designed around crunch and portion control.
Explore more classic and experimental flavors in the complete Crumbl cookie flavors list.
Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins FAQs
Final Verdict
The Cookies & Cream Crumbl Thins succeed only if you judge them as their own category—not as miniature versions of regular Crumbl cookies.
They offer:
- crunch,
- portion control,
- and reduced sweetness
instead of heavy frosting and oversized indulgence.
For some customers, that balance is exactly what Crumbl needed.
For others, it strips away the very identity that made the brand popular.
Either way, these cookies are one of the clearest signs that Crumbl is experimenting with where gourmet cookies can go next.
Explore more classic, frosted, and experimental flavors in the complete Crumbl cookie flavors list.